Stories · From The New Cyclopaedia of Prose Illustrations
Asked if he was a Calvinist, Newton took a lump of sugar, put it in his cup, and said he did not give it alone and whole.

John Newton, asked, Are you a Calvinist? said he was more of a Calvinist than anything else, but he used his Calvinism in writing and preaching as he did a piece of sugar. He took a lump, put it into his teacup, and stirred it. He said he did not give it alone and whole, but mixed and diluted.
He hoped he was, on the whole, a scriptural preacher, for he was considered an Arminian among the Calvinists and a Calvinist among the strenuous Arminians.
Source: New Cyclopaedia of Prose Illustrations (1875), public domain ("Calvinism, Newton's sugar").
